Why Buying a House is Financially Better Than Renting (Includes Calculator)
As a Chartered Financial Analyst with over 20 years of experience in real estate investing and financial services, I’ve seen firsthand the financial advantages of owning a home versus renting. I have rented to hundreds of families over the years and I’ve seen thousands of applications from tenants to rent.
I have also owned homes for decades. I know when it is better to rent than to buy a home. It depends on the person and how long they expect to live in the home. It also depends on how much they value flexibility and liquidity. There is nothing wrong with renting.
But in most cases, deciding whether to rent or buy a house (or anything) is a math problem. In this article I’ll help you understand that math problem. I’ll share the various reasons why buying a house is generally more financially beneficial than renting.
I also created a calculator that helped you decide if it makes more sense for you to rent or buy a home.
Table of Contents
The Financial Advantage of Fixed Mortgage Payments
One of the most significant benefits of buying a house is that mortgage payments are based on the present value of the house at the time of purchase. This means that once you lock in your mortgage rate, your monthly payments remain relatively stable over the life of the loan.
In contrast, rent is based on the present value at the time of renting and is subject to increase, often annually.
The Impact of Inflation
Inflation affects rent prices significantly. As the cost of living increases, so do rent prices. In contrast, a fixed-rate mortgage protects homeowners from these increases, making homeownership increasingly advantageous over time.
Essentially, while renters face ever-rising housing costs, homeowners enjoy the stability of predictable mortgage payments. This stability can provide peace of mind and allow for better long-term financial planning, as you are not subject to the whims of the rental market.
Tax Benefits of Homeownership
Homeownership provides several tax benefits that can significantly impact your financial situation. Here are the key advantages:
Mortgage Interest Deduction
One of the primary tax benefits of homeownership is the mortgage interest deduction. Homeowners can deduct the interest paid on their mortgage from their taxable income.
For mortgages taken out after December 15, 2017, the deduction is allowed on mortgage debt up to $750,000. For mortgages taken out before this date, the limit is $1 million.
This deduction can result in significant savings, especially in the early years of the mortgage when interest payments are higher, effectively reducing your taxable income and overall tax liability.
Property Tax Deduction
Homeowners can also deduct state and local property taxes, providing further tax relief. However, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) of 2017 imposed a cap of $10,000 ($5,000 if married filing separately) on the combined total of state and local income, sales, and property taxes.
Despite this cap, the property tax deduction can still contribute to significant tax savings for homeowners.
Capital Gains Exclusion
Another significant tax benefit is the capital gains exclusion when selling a primary residence. Homeowners can exclude up to $250,000 of capital gains from their taxable income, or $500,000 for married couples filing jointly.
To qualify, homeowners must have lived in the home for at least two of the five years preceding the sale. This exclusion allows homeowners to retain more profit from the sale of their home, providing a substantial financial advantage over renting.
The Cost of Moving
Moving frequently can be costly and time-consuming. The expenses associated with moving, such as hiring movers, renting trucks, and the time and effort involved, can add up to $1,000 to $3,000 or more each time you move. These costs can quickly add up, especially if you move every few years.
Homeownership encourages stability and can help you avoid these recurring costs. When you own a home, you have a greater incentive to stay put and invest in your property, rather than facing the disruption and expense of frequent moves.
This stability can also provide emotional benefits, as you can establish roots in a community and create a sense of permanence and belonging.
Benefits of Owning a House Compared to an Apartment
Owning a house offers several lifestyle advantages over renting an apartment. One of the most obvious benefits is the amount of space available. Houses typically offer more living space than apartments, including larger yards and more rooms. This additional space can provide a better quality of life, especially for families or those who value privacy and personal space.
Privacy is another significant advantage of homeownership. In an apartment, you often share walls with neighbors and may experience noise and disruptions. In contrast, owning a house often means more distance between neighbors and less noise. This can create a more peaceful and comfortable living environment.
Homeownership also allows for greater customization and personalization of your living space. When you own a home, you have the freedom to make changes and improvements to suit your tastes and needs.
Whether it’s painting walls, remodeling kitchens, or landscaping the yard, homeownership allows you to create a living space that truly feels like your own.
Break-Even Points: When It Makes Sense to Own
Determining the break-even point—the time at which buying becomes more advantageous than renting—depends on various factors, including the cost of the home, interest rates, and local market conditions. Generally, if you plan to stay in a home for at least three to five years, buying tends to be more financially beneficial.
This period allows you to build equity and offset the initial costs of purchasing a home, such as closing costs and moving expenses. Building equity means that as you pay down your mortgage, you increase your ownership stake in the property.
Over time, this can provide a substantial financial return, especially if the value of the property appreciates.
Additionally, the longer you stay in a home, the more you can benefit from the stability of fixed mortgage payments and the various tax advantages of homeownership. These factors can make a significant difference in your overall financial picture and help you build wealth over time.
Rent Vs Buy Break Even Calculator
I created this calculator to help you decide if it makes more sense for you financially to rent or buy a home.
How to Use the Rent vs. Buy Break-Even Calculator
This calculator helps you determine the break-even point for renting versus buying a home. The break-even point is the number of years it takes for the cost of buying a home to equal the cost of renting. Here’s how to use it:
- Monthly Rent ($): Enter your current monthly rent amount.
- Initial House Value ($): Enter the initial value of the house you are considering buying.
- Mortgage Amount ($): Enter the amount of the mortgage loan you plan to take out.
- Mortgage Term (years): Enter the number of years for your mortgage (e.g., 30 years).
- Interest Rate (%): Enter the annual interest rate for your mortgage.
- Property Tax Rate (% of house value): Enter the annual property tax rate as a percentage of the house value.
- Annual Maintenance (% of house value): Enter the annual maintenance costs as a percentage of the house value.
- Insurance Rate (% of house value): Enter the annual homeowners insurance rate as a percentage of the house value.
- Annual Appreciation Rate (%): Enter the expected annual appreciation rate for the house.
Using this calculator, you can better understand the financial implications of renting versus buying a home and make an informed decision based on your specific situation.
Rent vs. Buy Break-Even Calculator
Calculator created by Dad is FIRE
What the Output Means
- Break-Even Point: The calculator will display the break-even point in years. This is the number of years it will take for the total costs of buying the home to equal the total costs of renting.
- Total Rent Paid over Mortgage Term: This shows the total amount of rent you would pay over the mortgage term.
- Total Mortgage Paid over Mortgage Term: This shows the total amount paid towards the mortgage over the mortgage term.
- Total Home Ownership Cost over Mortgage Term: This includes the total costs of mortgage payments, property taxes, maintenance, and insurance over the mortgage term.
- Monthly Mortgage Payment: This shows the monthly mortgage payment amount.
- Annual Property Tax: This shows the annual property tax amount.
- Annual Maintenance Cost: This shows the annual maintenance cost.
- Annual Insurance Cost: This shows the annual homeowners insurance cost.
- Appreciated Value of Home after Mortgage Term: This shows the estimated value of the home after the mortgage term, considering the annual appreciation rate.
Things Omitted from This Calculator
While this calculator provides a useful estimate, it omits several factors that can impact the financial decision of renting versus buying:
- Renovation Costs: Home renovations and improvements can add significant value to a property but also come with additional costs.
- Renter’s Insurance: While homeowners pay for home insurance, renters also typically need renter’s insurance, which is not accounted for in this calculator.
- Tax Savings: Homeowners may benefit from tax deductions on mortgage interest and property taxes, which can lower the effective cost of homeownership.
- Homeowner Association (HOA) Fees: Some properties have HOA fees that can add to the monthly cost of owning a home.
- Utilities: The cost of utilities may differ between renting and owning, with some rentals including certain utilities in the rent.
- Maintenance and Repair Costs: While this calculator includes an estimate for annual maintenance, unexpected repairs can lead to additional costs.
- Opportunity Cost: The money used for a down payment and other buying costs could potentially be invested elsewhere, generating returns.
- Market Conditions: The real estate market can fluctuate, affecting property values and the cost of renting or buying over time.
By considering these additional factors, you can gain a more comprehensive understanding of the financial implications of renting versus buying a home.
Related: When Is The Best Time To Buy A House? A Real Estate Pro Answers.
When Renting is Advantageous
Despite the financial benefits of homeownership, there are situations where renting is more advantageous. Renting offers flexibility, making it ideal for those who need or prefer a more transient lifestyle.
If you plan to move within a few years, renting can be more cost-effective, as it allows you to avoid the upfront costs and commitment of buying a home.
Renting can also be advantageous for those who prioritize career mobility. If your job requires frequent relocations or if you anticipate changing jobs or cities, renting provides the flexibility to move without the need to sell a home. This can be particularly beneficial for young professionals or those in industries with high mobility.
Another advantage of renting is the lower upfront costs. Renting typically requires less cash upfront than buying a home, which can be beneficial if you’re saving for other financial goals, such as paying off debt or investing. Renters also avoid the ongoing costs of home maintenance and repairs, which can be significant.
Conclusion
While renting offers flexibility and lower upfront costs, the long-term financial benefits of owning a home generally outweigh the advantages of renting. Fixed mortgage payments, tax benefits, and the ability to build equity make homeownership a sound financial decision for those planning to stay in one place for several years.
As a Chartered Financial Analyst with extensive experience in real estate investing, I encourage you to consider your long-term financial goals and personal circumstances when deciding between buying and renting.
If you like what you just read, then subscribe to my newsletter.
