10 Reasons Why Section 8 Isn’t What You Think
Section 8 is one of the most misunderstood programs in real estate. Some believe it’s a guaranteed paycheck, others think it opens the door to endless tenant problems. The truth sits in the middle, if you understand what you’re getting into.
This post is about cutting through that noise. If you’re thinking about adding Section 8 rentals to your portfolio, you need to get past the myths and get to the facts.
So let’s clear the air. These are the most common Section 8 myths, and the real story behind each one.
Table of Contents
Why Listen to DadisFIRE
I bought my first rental at 21. Now, I’ve been a landlord and real estate investor for 24 years. I’ve bought more than a dozen properties, managed everything from tenant screenings to evictions, and lived through market crashes and booms.
I’m not guessing here, I’ve lived it. So if you’re looking for real advice, keep reading.
What Is Section 8?
The Section 8 Housing Choice Voucher Program, run by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), helps low-income families afford decent, safe housing in the private market.
It doesn’t own or operate properties. Instead, it pays a portion of the rent directly to private landlords, while tenants cover the rest.
As of recent HUD data, over $30 billion is spent annually on Section 8 housing assistance in the U.S. and more than 2 million families receive help through this program.
And yes, they rent single-family homes, apartments, and duplexes, just like the ones you might own or be looking to buy.
Unpopular Opinion: 10 Reasons Why An Expert Says Housing Is Actually Affordable
Myth #1: Section 8 Tenants Will Take Care of the Property
Assuming every Section 8 tenant will treat your unit like a model home is wishful thinking. The reality is that some will take care of it. Some won’t. And that has less to do with vouchers and more to do with individual habits.
The difference with Section 8 is that there are consequences built into the system. Tenants can lose their voucher if they damage a property or violate lease terms. That gives landlords more leverage than in typical market rentals, but it’s still not a guarantee.
Property damage can happen with any tenant. That’s why tenant screening, inspections, and solid lease terms matter more than just who’s paying the rent.
Related Video: What To Do When Tenant Destroys Rental Property
Myth #2: The Government Covers All Repairs
There’s no special repair fund or maintenance team that comes with a Section 8 tenant. The responsibility to maintain the unit such as plumbing, electrical, safety issues, pests is fully on the landlord.
Section 8 adds an extra layer: mandatory inspections based on Housing Quality Standards (HQS). If your property fails, the rent stops until it’s corrected. And those failures can be triggered by issues as small as peeling paint, missing outlet covers, or a broken handrail.
Expect higher standards and more scrutiny. If you’re not prepared to respond quickly to repair issues, this isn’t a passive investment, it becomes a full-time problem.
🙋♂️If this is interesting so far, follow DadisFIRE on MSN, then hit like to see more articles on financial freedom, personal finance, and smart money moves.💪
Myth #3: You Can Start With Little Cash in the Midwest
Midwest properties are often marketed as cheap entry points, but you’ll still need capital. Between down payments, closing costs, basic rehab, reserves, and compliance fixes, you’ll likely need $20,000 or more per property just to make the numbers work.
Lower prices don’t always mean better deals. Cheaper homes often need more repairs, have older infrastructure, and sit in neighborhoods that require extra management effort. And lenders aren’t jumping to finance bottom-dollar properties either.
If you’re undercapitalized, the Midwest won’t save you. It’ll expose you.
How To Buy a House with Little or No Money Down (I Have Done It Many Ways)
Myth #4: Turnkey Properties Don’t Need Any Repairs
“Turnkey” often means a property has been patched up just enough to pass inspection and get rented. It does not mean everything inside the house is new, updated, or problem-free.
Cosmetic updates can hide deeper issues, like outdated wiring, leaky plumbing, or worn-out HVAC systems. Some turnkeys need immediate repairs after closing. Others work fine for a few months, then start falling apart.
Even with a turnkey, smart investors budget for unexpected expenses. The goal isn’t perfection, it’s preparation.
🙋♂️If you like what you are reading so far, subscribe to the DadisFIRE newsletter and follow DadisFIRE on YouTube.💪
Myth #5: Section 8 Tenants Are Mostly One Racial Group
A lot of people assume Section 8 is dominated by one race. Usually it’s tied to stereotypes about who lives in “low-income” housing. Wrong.
HUD’s own data shows Section 8 serves a diverse mix: about 48% Black, 23% White, 22% Hispanic, and the rest other groups, varying by region.
Voucher holders come from all backgrounds, and the only thing they have in common is needing affordable rent.
The program’s about income, not race. Assuming otherwise blinds you to the real tenant pool and can make you miss out on great renters. Screen for character and history, not preconceived notions.
Myth #6: Any Lender Will Finance Low-Cost Rentals
Many new investors underestimate how strict lenders are about minimum loan amounts. This isn’t about credit. It’s about profitability for the lender. Processing a small mortgage costs them almost the same as a large one, with much smaller returns.
Unless you’re bringing a larger portfolio or can group multiple properties, financing low-cost rentals can be a challenge. Expect to use cash, find niche lenders, or explore creative financing just to close.
Is An Adjustable Rate Mortgage a Good Idea?
Myth #7: Section 8 Doesn’t Require Frequent Inspections
Annual inspections are standard under Section 8, but additional checks can happen too, especially when tenants report issues or during move-outs. These inspections follow federal guidelines under HUD, and failure means rent gets held until everything’s fixed and cleared.
Inspections aren’t just for major repairs. You can get flagged for chipped paint, worn carpet, or a missing screen window. Even if the tenant caused the issue, you’re still on the hook to fix it.
This isn’t a set-it-and-forget-it system. It requires active maintenance and fast response times. If you’re slow to act, it costs you.
Myth #8: Section 8 Housing Only Exists in Bad Neighborhoods
This might be the most persistent and misleading myth of all. Section 8 isn’t tied to specific neighborhoods. It’s a voucher, not a zip code. That means tenants can live in a wide range of areas, including those with high home values, good schools, and low crime rates.
I live next to one of the wealthiest zip codes in my state, and yes, there are Section 8 properties there. It’s one way families can access stronger school districts or safer streets without market-rate rent prices. You wouldn’t know it driving through, and that’s the point.
Landlords who limit their search to “low-income” areas based on this myth are missing a key opportunity. Section 8 is everywhere. You just have to look.
25 Areas Home Buyers Instantly HATE About Your Home
Myth #9: Section 8 Rent Payments Are Always On Time
The idea of government-backed rent sounds like a direct deposit dream, but it’s not always clockwork. HUD payments are reliable, but delays can happen.
Paperwork snafus, inspection holds, or changes in tenant eligibility can slow things down. I’ve waited weeks for a payment when a new tenant’s voucher approval got tangled in red tape.
Market tenants can miss rent too, but with Section 8, you’re dealing with a bureaucracy. Always have a cash reserve to cover gaps, and stay on top of communication with your local housing authority to avoid surprises.
Myth #10: You Can Charge Premium Rents with Section 8
Some landlords think they can jack up rent because the government’s footing most of the bill. Not so fast. Section 8 rents are capped by Fair Market Rents (FMRs) set by HUD, based on local market data.
If your property’s in a hot area, you might be stuck charging less than you could get from a market tenant.
You can sometimes negotiate slightly higher rents for premium features, but it’s not a free-for-all. Check the FMR for your area before buying, or you might be locked into lower cash flow than you planned.
Rethinking Section 8 Housing
Section 8 isn’t all good or all bad, it’s a system with real rules, real risks, and real potential. The horror stories get clicks, but most problems come down to poor planning, weak reserves, or ignoring the fine print.
It’s not a quick win, and it’s definitely not passive if you only own one. But for investors who run it like a business, the stability and scale can work. Government rent doesn’t mean guaranteed profit, it just adds a different kind of management.
Know what you’re signing up for, and treat it like the long game it is.
🙋♂️If you like what you just read, subscribe to the DadisFIRE newsletter and follow DadisFIRE on YouTube. 💪 Also be sure to follow DadisFIRE on MSN💰
