A Dad’s Eye-Opening Conversation About Compliments: What I Learned About Raising Daughters

I had an unexpected but enlightening conversation with a close friend the other day, and it made me rethink how I’m raising my twin daughters. I’ve always thought of compliments as a way to build confidence and show love, especially as a dad.
I tell my girls all the time that they’re beautiful, and I mean it from the bottom of my heart. They’re smart, strong, and adventurous, but “beautiful” just comes out so naturally, like it’s the highest compliment I could give them.
But then, I had this conversation with my friend, who’s in her 30s, and it changed everything. I was spending time with her and her dad, just chatting, when her dad casually called her beautiful as a compliment.
I noticed something in her body language. It was a subtle shift, but it was clear to me that she didn’t like it.
Her reaction surprised me, and I was curious. So, after her dad walked away, I asked her why she seemed bothered by the compliment.
She brushed it off at first, but I gently pressed, explaining that as a dad myself, I tell my five-year-old twins all the time how beautiful they are. I wanted to understand what was going on.
Her answer was an epiphany for me, one I hadn’t anticipated.
She said, “Imagine what message society sends attractive girls. All of the compliments and feedback they get their entire life is around their appearance.”
And then she added, “I’m smart, too. But people always seem surprised by that. When I get feedback on my intelligence, it’s as if it’s unexpected or unbelievable. It’s like my looks cancel out the possibility of being smart.”
Her words hit me like a ton of bricks. I had never thought about it like that before. What I thought was a harmless compliment actually had layers of complexity for her.
It wasn’t that she disliked being called beautiful. Instead it was the imbalance. Most of the praise she had received throughout her life revolved around her appearance.
Compliments on her intelligence or her achievements were often accompanied by an air of skepticism, as if people couldn’t reconcile her being both attractive and intelligent.
That dichotomy had followed her throughout her life and caused her to place an uncomfortable amount of value on her looks, simply because that’s how society had always identified her.
She told me something that really stuck with me: “It’s hard to find value in yourself in other ways when everyone identifies you by your appearance. It causes obsessions over maintaining that appearance for fear it will go away.”
She wasn’t complaining. She was helping me, as a dad, understand something that I could do differently for my daughters. It was a gift of insight. And it came with a very practical takeaway.
I asked her what I could do to avoid unintentionally contributing to this experience for my girls. Her advice was simple but profound: “Change the ratio. Make sure the majority of your compliments are about things other than their looks.
Society will give them plenty of feedback on their appearance. You can help build their confidence in other areas like their intelligence, their kindness, their creativity, their strength.”
Table of Contents
Why This Conversation Was an Epiphany for Me as a Dad
As parents, we all want the best for our kids. We want them to feel confident, loved, and capable. For dads of daughters, in particular, there’s a natural inclination to tell them they’re beautiful.
In many ways, it feels like a way to protect them from a world that’s often harsh, especially when it comes to female appearance standards. I always thought telling my daughters they were beautiful would shield them from some of the societal pressure to look a certain way.
I believed that if they knew their beauty came from me, their dad. I am their biggest supporter. I assumed they’d be less affected by the outside world’s judgment.
But I now realize that while my intentions were good, I may have been unintentionally reinforcing the very thing I was trying to protect them from.
The Impact of Appearance-Based Compliments
From a young age, girls are often showered with compliments about their looks. Whether it’s their pretty dress, their cute smile, or their shiny hair, appearance becomes a central focus of their identity.
Over time, this can shape how they see themselves. They may start to believe that their value is tied to how they look, and as my friend pointed out, it can lead to an obsession with maintaining that appearance.
The Pressure of Living Up to Beauty Standards
My friend explained that as someone who’s always been considered “attractive,” she felt a constant pressure to meet society’s expectations of beauty. It wasn’t just about looking good.
It was also about maintaining that standard at all costs. For her, this pressure extended into every aspect of her life. She became hyper-aware of her appearance and feared what might happen if she didn’t live up to the “beautiful” label she had been given.
As a dad, I can see how this might be especially damaging for young girls who are still forming their self-esteem.
The Surprising Reaction to Intelligence
What really struck me was when my friend said that whenever people acknowledged her intelligence, it often came as a surprise. It’s as if people couldn’t believe she could be both smart and attractive.
This constant skepticism about her intelligence devalued her sense of self-worth in that area. It made her feel like no matter how smart she was, it would always be overshadowed by her looks. For someone who prides themselves on being smart, that’s a tough pill to swallow.
Finding Value Beyond Appearance
My friend’s experience highlighted something crucial: When girls are primarily complimented on their looks, they might struggle to find value in other aspects of themselves.
This can lead to an unbalanced sense of self-worth, where appearance becomes the dominant factor in their identity. For my daughters, I don’t want their looks to be the main thing they rely on to feel good about themselves.
I want them to value their minds, their creativity, their kindness, and their resilience just as much, if not more.
How I’m Changing the Way I Compliment My Daughters
Since that conversation, I’ve been much more intentional about the compliments I give my girls. Don’t get me wrong. I still tell them they’re beautiful. But now, I make sure that’s just one part of a much bigger picture.
I compliment their problem-solving skills when they figure out a tricky puzzle. I tell them how proud I am of their kindness when they share with each other. I praise their creativity when they come up with a new game or drawing.
Here’s what I’ve started focusing on more:
1) Praising Effort and Determination
Instead of only commenting on the final outcome, I’ve started to focus on the effort they put into things. When my daughters try hard at something, whether it’s building a tower of blocks or learning a new dance move, I make sure to acknowledge their hard work and persistence. It’s not about perfection. Instead it’s about the process.
2) Recognizing Emotional Strength
I’ve made it a point to highlight their emotional resilience. If one of them gets upset but manages to calm herself down, I tell her how proud I am of her for handling her emotions. Emotional intelligence is a strength I want them to carry with them throughout life.
3) Celebrating Intelligence and Curiosity
I’ve begun to emphasize their intellectual achievements more. Whether they’re asking questions about how something works or figuring out how to solve a problem, I praise their curiosity and intelligence. I want them to know that their minds are powerful and capable.
4) Appreciating Kindness and Empathy
When my daughters show kindness, whether it’s toward each other or someone else, I make sure to point it out. The world could always use more kindness, and I want them to know that their ability to empathize and care for others is something to be celebrated.
5) Valuing Creativity and Imagination
I’ve learned to acknowledge their creativity more. If they come up with a new game, draw a picture, or make up a story, I tell them how impressed I am by their imagination. I want them to see creativity as a valuable and important part of who they are.
Why This Matters for Raising Confident Girls
Society will continue to place a heavy emphasis on appearance, especially for girls. It’s something I can’t shield my daughters from entirely. But what I can do is create a different narrative at home. By focusing on their strengths beyond their looks, I can help build a foundation of self-worth that isn’t tied to something as fleeting as appearance.
As my friend said, society will give them plenty of feedback on their looks. My job as their dad is to balance that out by reinforcing their other strengths, giving them the tools they need to feel confident in all aspects of themselves.
I think about the kind of women I want my daughters to grow up to be—strong, confident, kind, intelligent, and self-assured. I want them to know that their value comes from who they are, not just what they look like. And now, I know that starts with me.
The Ripple Effect of Positive Reinforcement
What I’ve come to understand is that how we compliment our children doesn’t just affect how they see themselves in the present. It shapes the foundation of their confidence for years to come.
When my daughters are teenagers, young adults, and even grown women, I want them to carry with them the belief that they are capable, intelligent, and strong, beyond anything society says about their appearance.
My friend’s experience is a testament to how much weight we put on appearance. She wasn’t complaining or asking for sympathy.
She was helping me realize that my girls will also grow up in a world where their looks will be constantly evaluated. But if I can help them build their confidence in their intellect, creativity, kindness, and resilience, then they’ll be better equipped to handle those societal pressures.
Shaping the Next Generation
We all play a role in shaping the next generation’s sense of self. Whether you’re a parent, an aunt or uncle, a teacher, or simply someone who interacts with children, your words matter.
Compliments about appearance can be part of the conversation, but they shouldn’t dominate it. Kids need to hear that they are more than what they look like. They are thinkers, problem-solvers, creators, and caregivers.
And it goes beyond just girls. Boys, too, benefit from being told that their value isn’t tied solely to their physical strength or appearance. Boys need to hear that it’s okay to be kind, to be empathetic, and to value their minds as much as their bodies.
A Beautiful Lesson Learned
As a dad, my conversation with my friend was a turning point. I now approach compliments with more thoughtfulness and intentionality. I still tell my daughters they’re beautiful, but it’s no longer the default praise I give.
I make sure to tell them they’re smart when they figure something out. I remind them how strong they are when they show perseverance. I praise their creativity when they come up with new ideas, and I encourage their kindness when they show empathy.
In doing this, I’m not just complimenting them. I’m helping them see the full spectrum of their abilities and strengths. I’m giving them the tools to build confidence in who they are as people, not just what they look like.
To all the dads (and moms) out there, take this as a reminder: our kids are watching, listening, and absorbing everything we say. Let’s make sure we’re building them up in ways that will truly last, well beyond the fleeting nature of looks.
Let’s raise kids who know they are valued for everything they are, and not just what they look like.
This journey of parenting is full of learning moments, and I’m thankful for the conversations that help me grow as a father.
Now, I’m ready to do my part to help my daughters find confidence in every aspect of who they are, from their minds to their hearts to their bodies. After all, that’s what being a dad is really about: helping them become the best versions of themselves.
🙋♂️Ready to take charge of your financial future? Subscribe to the DadisFIRE newsletter and follow Dad is FIRE on YouTube for more insights on financial independence and smart money management.💪